Depends ENTIRELY upon these:
1) Maintenance intervals--shoddy maintenance equals shoddy longevity.
2) Driven miles--City, Highway, both.
3) Driven characteristics--Rough (foot down mostly, rough cornering, etc.), easy (driven like someone with sense).
I would go with the Honda just because of LONGEVITY of aligned Models and it has LESS miles.
ANY VEHICLE can look sporty sitting still.
DEPENDABLE equals SPORTY, but if what a vehicle LOOKS LIKE to yourself and others, good luck.
I would rather ride a Honda Motorcycle than PUSH a Harley-Davidson and while the honda may not LOOK GOOD, it IS DEPENDABLE.