Is trading a 2001 Pontiac Montana for a 1995 Dodge Ram 1500 a good trade?

[Dan T]

Same mileage. The Montana's gas gage doesn't work. The Ram has some rust on the fenders and a cracked windshield. Both have some minor mechanical issues.

 

[mccoyblues]

One POS for another. If you need the pick up more than the van then Yes, its a good trade.